FIVE MORE people were convicted in Minneapolis Wednesday (Dec. 12) for their role in a huge sex trafficking operation involving women from Thailand.
U.S. Attorney Erica MacDonald described the case as one of the largest trafficking networks ever dismantled at the federal level.
“Sex trafficking is an industry that is built on supply and demand, and this organization fed that industry,” MacDonald said after the court proceedings. “It exploited, it abused, enslaved and sold women in response to the high demand for commercial sex that exists not only in the United States but here in Minnesota.”
The defendants were Michael Morris, 65, of Seal Beach, California; Pawinee Unpradit, 46, of Dallas; Saowapha Thinram, 44, of Hutto, Texas; Thoucharin Ruttanamongkongul, 35, of Chicago; and Waralee Wanless, 39, of Colony, Texas.
During the six-week trial, prosecutors accused that the defendants ran a sex trafficking operation that lasted more than a decade and crossed international borders with 34 co-conspirators, who pleaded guilty in earlier proceedings.
As proven at trial, this criminal organization compelled hundreds of women from Bangkok, Thailand, to engage in commercial sex acts in various cities across the United States, including Minneapolis, Los Angeles, Chicago, Atlanta, Phoenix, Washington, D.C., Las Vegas, Houston, Dallas, Seattle and Austin.
After a six-week trail, jurors returned their verdict barely a day after receiving the case.
Two waves of defendants from across the country were charged in the case, beginning in October 2016 and again in May 2017. All pleaded guilty to avoid trial except for the five who were recently convicted.
Prosecutors described the case as “modern-day sex slavery” and argued that the defendants forced Thai women to work long hours having sex with multiple men daily to pay off “bondage debts” owed to traffickers for help coming to the United States. Prosecutors said victims, some of whom testified during the trial, were misled as to how much they truly owed and were threatened if they tried to leave the business.
The trafficking victims were often from impoverished backgrounds and spoke little or no English. They were coerced to participate in the criminal scheme through misleading promises of a better life in the United States and the ability to provide money to their families in Thailand.
Once in the United States, the victims were sent to houses of prostitution where they were forced to have sex with strangers – every day – for up to 12 hours a day, at times having sex with 10 men a day, said the prosecutors. The victims were isolated from the outside world. They were not allowed to leave the houses of prostitution unless accompanied by a member of the criminal organization. The victims moved around the United States between houses of prostitution in multiple cities. They and their families in Thailand were threatened.
The operation dealt primarily in cash and used it's international connections to launder millions of dollars.
“The defendants convicted yesterday participated in a massive yet brutally efficient criminal enterprise that trafficked hundreds of vulnerable Thai women for sexual exploitation and used sophisticated money laundering techniques to conceal and sustain itself,” said Assistant Attorney General Brian A. Benczkowski of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division.
To date, investigators have been able to recover $1.5 million in cash and $15 million in money judgments secured through plea agreements. During the extensive investigation, law enforcement traced tens of millions of dollars to the organization. Indeed, at trial, there was testimony that more than $40 million was sent to Thailand by one money launderer alone.
“We feel pretty confident that based on the number of important-position folks we are taking down, we’ll really hurt this organization,” said Alex Khu, special agent in charge of Homeland Security Investigations in Minneapolis. “It will take down this ring.”
BACKGROUNDER
For traffickers, Thailand is a land of opportunity. Trafficking in this tourist hotspot is a roughly $12 billion industry — a bigger cash earner than the country’s drug trade, according to the International Labor Organization.
Thailand has climbed to an eight-year high, earning a Tier 2 ranking in the latest US Trafficking in Person (TIP) report launched by the US State Department. Tier 3 being the lowest rating.
While many are heartened by the Thai government’s success, a labor rights advocate notes that there is still room for improvement, especially concerning corruption and the victim screening process.
An annual State Dept. report. "Trafficking in Persons Report 2018," released last summer in Washington, said that the Thai government had demonstrated increased efforts to address slavery and human trafficking.
Increased prosecutions, convictions of traffickers and a decrease in prosecution time for trafficking cases through the use of a specialized anti-trafficking law enforcement division were positively cited in the report.
______________________________________________________________________________
Jurors returned guilty verdicts on all counts Wednesday afternoon, barely
a day after receiving the case following six weeks of trial. Two waves of defendants from across the country were charged in the case, beginning in October 2016 and again in May 2017. All but five pleaded guilty to avoid trial. Prosecutors described the case as “modern-day sex slavery” and argued that the defendants forced Thai women to work long hours having sex with multiple men daily to pay off “bondage debts” owed to traffickers for help coming to the United States. Prosecutors said victims,
some of whom testified during the trial, were misled as to how much they truly owed and were threatened if they tried to leave the business.
Five defendants were convicted yesterday by a federal jury for their roles in operating a massive international sex trafficking organization that was responsible for coercing hundreds of Thai women to engage in commercial sex acts across the United States.
Michael Morris, 65, of Seal Beach, California; Pawinee Unpradit, 46, of Dallas, Texas; Saowapha Thinram, 44, of Hutto, Texas; Thoucharin Ruttanamongkongul, 35, of Chicago Illinois; and Waralee Wanless, 39, of The Colony, Texas, were convicted following a six-week trial before Senior Judge Donovan Frank in U.S. District Court in St. Paul, Minnesota. Thirty-one defendants previously pleaded guilty for their roles in the sex trafficking organization.
The convictions were announced yesterday by U.S. Attorney Erica H. MacDonald for the District of Minnesota, Assistant Attorney General Brian A. Benczkowski of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division, Assistant Attorney General Eric Dreiband for the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division, Special Agent in Charge Tracy J. Cormier of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) St. Paul, Supervisory Special Agent Todd Strom of IRS Criminal Investigation (IRS-CI) and Directing Attorney Panida Rzonca for the Thai Community Development Center.
“More than two years ago, my office filed the first federal indictment against a criminal organization that relied on the sexual exploitation of women for their own financial gain,” said U.S. Attorney MacDonald. “Since then, our team of prosecutors and investigators systematically dismantled the organization, while seeking justice for every victim of this organization. The process has been long, but today’s guilty verdict represents both a successful and just outcome. While our work combatting human trafficking continues, this case stands as a powerful example of the Department of Justice's commitment to achieving justice for victims. I applaud our law enforcement partners for the remarkable dedication and collaboration they have demonstrated throughout this process.”
“The defendants convicted yesterday participated in a massive yet brutally efficient criminal enterprise that trafficked hundreds of vulnerable Thai women for sexual exploitation and used sophisticated money laundering techniques to conceal and sustain itself,” said Assistant Attorney General Brian A. Benczkowski of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division. “The Criminal Division, through our Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section, is committed to working with our law enforcement partners to dismantle the financial infrastructure supporting criminal organizations such as these.”
“Sex trafficking is a horrific crime that seeks to erode the human dignity of victims," said Assistant Attorney General Eric Dreiband for the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division. “I want to thank U.S. Attorney Erica H. MacDonald, the District of Minnesota’s Anti-Trafficking Coordination Team, HSI St. Paul, IRS Criminal Investigations, the State Department’s Diplomatic Security Service, and other law enforcement and local partners for their hard work on this case which dismantled an extensive transnational trafficking enterprise. The Department of Justice will bring the full force of the law against perpetrators of sex trafficking crimes.”
“The convictions of these defendants close this chapter for law enforcement, however mark only the beginning of the recovery process for the victims,” said Special Agent in Charge Comier. “I am extremely proud of the work done by HSI’s special agents, and of the teamwork demonstrated by our law enforcement partners in dismantling this criminal organization. Our communities are safer as a result of this investigation.”
“The cruel and illegal actions of the defendants tear at the fabric of our community, causing trauma, fear and anguish both seen and unseen,” said St. Paul Police Chief Axtell. “Thankfully, due to the exceptional work of many law enforcement agencies and their representatives, the guilty will be held accountable for their actions and survivors will get help, support and justice.”
“The guilty verdict of these five individuals received yesterday is the culmination of a large sophisticated international sex trafficking criminal enterprise," said IRS-CI Special Agent in Charge Strom. "This criminal organization exploited women and laundered hundreds of thousands of illicit profits. Pooling the skills of each agency in this complex investigation made a tremendous team including IRS Criminal Investigation who provided the financial expertise to follow the money trail of these criminals. Today’s guilty verdict demonstrates the collective efforts of law enforcement and U.S. Attorney’s Office who brought down an international sex trafficking organization.”
As proven at trial, this criminal organization compelled hundreds of women from Bangkok, Thailand, to engage in commercial sex acts in various cities across the United States, including Minneapolis, Los Angeles, Chicago, Atlanta, Phoenix, Washington, D.C., Las Vegas, Houston, Dallas, Seattle and Austin. The trafficking victims were often from impoverished backgrounds and spoke little or no English. They were coerced to participate in the criminal scheme through misleading promises of a better life in the United States and the ability to provide money to their families in Thailand.
Once in the United States, the victims were sent to houses of prostitution where they were forced to have sex with strangers – every day – for up to 12 hours a day, at times having sex with 10 men a day. The victims were isolated from the outside world. They were not allowed to leave the houses of prostitution unless accompanied by a member of the criminal organization. The victims moved around the United States between houses of prostitution in multiple cities. They and their families in Thailand were threatened.
The organization also engaged in widespread visa fraud to facilitate the international transportation of the victims. Traffickers assisted the victims in obtaining fraudulent visas and travel documents by funding false bank accounts, creating fictitious backgrounds and occupations, and instructing the victims to enter into fraudulent marriages to increase the likelihood that their visa applications would be approved. Traffickers also coached the victims as to what to say during their visa interviews. While working to obtain visa documents, traffickers gathered personal information from the victims, including the location of the victims’ families in Thailand. This information was later used to threaten victims who sought to flee the organization in the United States.
The organization dealt primarily in cash and engaged in rampant and sophisticated money laundering in order to promote and conceal illegal profits. The organization used “funnel accounts” to launder and route cash from cities across the United States to the money launderers in Los Angeles. To date, investigators have been able to recover $1.5 million in cash and $15 million in money judgments secured through plea agreements. During the extensive investigation, law enforcement traced tens of millions of dollars to the organization. Indeed, at trial, there was testimony that more than $40 million was sent to Thailand by one money launderer alone.
The District of Minnesota is one of six districts designated through a nationwide selection process as a Phase II Anti-Trafficking Coordination Team (ACTeam), an ACTeam Initiative of the Departments of Justice, Homeland Security and Labor. ACTeams focus on developing high-impact human trafficking investigations and prosecutions involving forced labor, international sex trafficking and sex trafficking by force, fraud or coercion through interagency collaboration among federal prosecutors and federal investigative agencies. Today’s convictions validate the continued ACTeam mission—to take on and take down the most entrenched and sophisticated human trafficking organizations that seek to profit from human exploitation.
U.S. Attorney MacDonald, Assistant Attorney General Benczkowski and Assistant Attorney General Dreiband commended the multiple agencies that assisted in this investigation over the past three years including: HSI; IRS-CI; the Department of Justice’s Criminal Division’s Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section; the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division’s Human Trafficking Prosecution Unit; the St. Paul Police Department; the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension’s Minnesota Human Trafficking Investigators Task Force; the Anoka County Sheriff’s Office; the Cook County (Illinois) Sheriff’s Office; the State Department Diplomatic Security Service; and the International Organized Crime Intelligence and Operations Center (IOC-2). U.S. Attorney MacDonald also thanks the Thai Community Development Center for the support and advocacy they have done on behalf of the victims of this sex trafficking organization.
U.S. Attorney MacDonald, Assistant Attorney General Benczkowski and Assistant Attorney General Dreiband further thanked the trial team led by Assistant U.S. Attorneys Melinda A. Williams and Laura Provinzino, with assistance from HSI Special Agent Tonya Price, IRS-CI Special Agent John Tschida, Senior Investigator Steven Baker of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division’s Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section, and the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division’s Human Trafficking Prosecution Unit for their dedication to the pursuit of justice
This case is filed as United States v. Michael Morris, et al., 17-cr-107 (DWF/TNL) and United States v. Sumalee Intarathong, et al., 16-cr-257 (DWF/TNL).
Defendants:
MICHAEL J. MORRIS, 65
Seal Beach, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Sex trafficking by use of force, fraud, and coercion, 1 count
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
Conspiracy to use a communication facility to promote prostitution, 1 count
PAWINEE UNPRADIT, 46
Dallas, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
Conspiracy to use a communication facility to promote prostitution, 1 count
SAOWAPHA THINRAM, 44
Hutto, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
Conspiracy to use a communication facility to promote prostitution, 1 count
THOUCHARIN RUTTANAMONGKONGUL, 35
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
Conspiracy to use a communication facility to promote prostitution, 1 count
WARALEE WANLESS, 39
The Colony, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
Conspiracy to use a communication facility to promote prostitution, 1 count
CHATARAK TAUFFLIEB, 52
San Jose, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PEERACHET THIPBOONNGAM, 58
Los Angeles, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
GREGORY ALLEN KIMMY, 38
Hutto, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
WILAIWAN PHIMKHALEE, 40
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
KANYARAT CHAIWIRAT, 52
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PORNTHEP SUKPRASERT, 42
Huntington Beach, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
MULCHULEE CHALERMSAKULRAT, 41
Huntington Beach, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
BHUNNA WIN, 51
San Diego, Calif.
Convicted:
Unlicensed money transmitting business, 1 count
NATCHANOK YUVASUTA, 50
Los Angeles, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
NATTAYA LEELARUNGRAYAB, 47
Los Angeles, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PEERASAK GUNTETONG, 61
North Hollywood, CA
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
VEERAPON GHETTALAE, 57
Lake Elsinore, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
MATTHEW MINTZ, 27
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit alien harboring, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
MOHIT TANDON, 38
Burr Ridge, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
RICHARD ALEXANDER, 53
DeKalb, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit marriage fraud, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
TANAKRON PATRATH, 60
Houston, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PANWAD KHOTPRATOOM, 47
Houston, Texas
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
CHABAPRAI BOONLUEA, 44
Winder, Ga.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
NOPPAWAN LERSLURCHACHAI, 37
Lomita, Calif.
Convicted:
Sex trafficking by use of force, fraud, and coercion, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
WATCHARIN LUAMSEEJUN, 48
Unknown
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PANTILA RODPHOKHA, 33
Mount Prospect, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
SOYSUDA SIANGDANG, 34
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
ANDREW FLANIGAN, 53
Winder, Ga.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
TODD VASSEY, 56
Lahanina, Hawaii
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
THI VU, 50
Atlanta, Ga.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
JOHN ZBRACKI, 61
Lakeville, Minn.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
JOHN NG, 41
Cottage Grove, Minn.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to commit transportation to engage in prostitution, 1 count
Conspiracy to engage in money laundering, 1 count
PATCHARAPORN SAENGKHAM, 43
Los Angeles, Calif.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to enter the United States by means of misrepresentation and concealment of facts, 1 count
CHANANCHIDA SENASU, 42
Dallas, Tex.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to enter the United States by means of misrepresentation and concealment of facts, 1 count
YADAPORN PANNGOEN, 32
Chicago, Ill.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to enter the United States by means of misrepresentation and concealment of facts, 1 count
CHONTHICHA SOICHAISONG, 38
Austin, Tex.
Convicted:
Conspiracy to enter the United States by means of misrepresentation and concealment of facts, 1 count
Topic(s):
Human Trafficking
