Heather Chin/Billy Penn Arena opponents celebrated upon hearing the new of the Chinatown sports complex. |
Philadelphians have staved off a project that could have ruined the Chinatown community. The big sports complex which would have wreaked havoc on the city's Chinatown will be built elsewhere, say opponents of the development.
“Chinatown is beyond a commercial area. Chinatown is a home for many people. It’s a community for all of us,” said Wei Chen, civic engagement director with Asian Americans United, one of the groups opposing the construction of an arena in the city's Chinatown. “We come here for service. We come here for temple. We come here for celebrations. This is our home."The complex to be shared by the National Basketball League's 76ers and the National Hockey League's Flyers will be built in South Philadelphia where the Sixers' current arena is located.
RELATED: Are Chinatowns in the United States being squeezed out of cities?
After years of contentious hearings and noisy demonstrations, the sports teams made their announcement Jan. 13 to the cheers of Philadelphia's neighborhood advocates and Chinatown residents who feared the proposed complex would ruin the character of the city's thriving Chinatown, create traffic gridlock and encourage rent-raising gentrification.
"We didn’t really change our mind. We were really committed to Market East … but our North Star was to do the right thing by Philly,” said 76ers owner Josh Harris. “We felt we could build a better arena and also revitalize Market East … so we pivoted.”
The proposed relocated sports and entertainment complex dubbed the South Philadelphia Sports Complex, will be the new home of the Philadelphia 76ers and Philadelphia Flyers.
“Over the past two years, Philly built a movement not only to save Chinatown, but to defend our entire city from predatory billionaires who saw us for a profit playground, and tens of thousands of Philadelphians showed up. When some said it was a done deal, this movement stayed true, committed to a different kind of city,” said the No Arena coalition in a statement.
Sharon Chen, a family nurse practitioner in Philly’s Chinatown, said she “cried tears of joy ... knowing that at least for now, Chinatown as a community will not be disrupted, and that anyone who needs to be rushed to Jefferson Hospital by ambulance will not be killed by gridlock traffic.”
Though the arena proposal is moving, a new project is in the works for the Center City with the addition of the Comcast Corporation as a new partner in the complex.
“From the start, we envisioned a project that would be transformative for our city and deliver the type of experience our fans deserve. By coming together with Brian and Comcast, this partnership ensures Philadelphia will have two developments instead of one, creating more jobs and real, sustainable economic opportunity,” said Josh Harris, David Blitzer, and David Adelman, of the Harris, Blitzer Sports Entertainment., project developers
Critics feared the sports arena woud have changed the character of Philadelphia's Cchinatown |
“We are grateful to Mayor Parker, Council President Johnson, Council Member Squilla, Governor Shapiro, our partners in labor and the many community and business leaders who supported us throughout this process. This is a massive win for our fans and for the city.”
Neighborhood activists tempered their celebration with a note of caution as they awaiti proposals for the new Chinatown project that could still transform the neighborhood. The difference, advocates hope, is that planning for the new project will include input from the neighborhood residents, something that was missing in the arena proposal.
“There was not an inclusive process to hear the community’s voice,” Chen, whose group was part of a coalition to oppose the arena, said Chen.“Almost each day since we’ve announced, we’ve had a meeting with a different group within the community,” previously said David Adelman, an entrepreneur who’s leading the project for the team.
The battle between the neighborhood and developers has left a feeling a sour taste in the mouths of neighborhood businesses and advocates regarding the new Center City development, whatever that may be.
Mohan Seshadri, executive director at the Asian Pacific Islander Political Alliance, echoed a similar sentiment.
“We are so proud and happy and relieved that Chinatown, a 150-year-old community, will continue to stand strong,” said Asian Pacific Islander Political Alliance executive director Mohan Seshadri during a press conference.
“But let’s be clear, it didn’t have to be like this. None of this had to be like this when we said, two and a half years ago, that this arena was the wrong site, the wrong location for a project like this. That it was going to destroy Chinatown.”
City leaders and developers, however, believe they've learned a lesson from the original project.
The entrance to Philadelphia's Chinatown. |
“We firmly believe we are better working together for Philadelphia,” said Dan Hilferty, Chairman and CEO of Comcast Spectacor. “This new arena will complement other exciting developments in the area, including Comcast Spectacor’s and the Philadelphia Phillies’ plans to create the country’s top sports and entertainment district. We will all work closely together to create an unmatched experience for the fans while developing a vibrant mixed-use district that serves our community.”
Chinatown residents and neighborhood advocates have also learned their lesson and may give an indication of whats ahead.
“Two-and-a-half years ago, every single person told us that it was a done deal,” said Mohan Seshadri, executive director of API PA, which advocates for Asian Pacific Islanders’ civil rights in Pennsylvania. “And then we talked to our elders and our leaders and communities all across the city, and they said no way is this a done deal. We’re going to fight.”